Skip to main content

The Dissecting Room

Thirty years ago none wished to look at the body of a murderer. Now the desire for knowledge induces many to overcome their prejudices and not only look at the dead body, but to hunt it out in the dissection room, and to examine all the bumps on the head, and compare the resemblance to the penny woodcuts.

Dr George James Guthrie, 1829

The consolidation of the Australian penal colonies coincided with the advent of purportedly scientific theories that sought to understand human behaviour through an analysis of the body – specifically the study of the skull and facial features.

Though initially developed by physicians, phrenology was taken up by certain non-medical practitioners who applied the theory to social questions such as education and criminal reform. With their convict and ex-convict populations, the Australian settlements represented a rich vein of material and a regular, powerless source of subjects for officials engaged in the consideration of such ideas. Colonial-era surgeons – and, subsequently, university medical departments – utilised executed felons for dissection, and analysed post-mortem portraits for evidence of the physiological causes of criminality.

A concern that innate criminal tendencies could be passed on to subsequent generations resulted in the creation of death masks, which were collected and studied by anatomists and used as props in lectures delivered by practical and travelling phrenologists. For much of the 19th century, portraits of dead criminals were also put to commercial uses, such as in the production of lithographed souvenirs of malefactors, or in the ghoulish and sensationalised waxworks displays of bushrangers and assorted infamous offenders.

4 portraits

1Phrenology video: 3 minutes 25 seconds. 2Alexander Pearce
executed for murder
July 19th 1824
. 3John Knatchbull, c. 1844 an unknown artist. 4Donohoe c.1830, attributed to Thomas Mitchell (1792-1855).
© National Portrait Gallery 2019
King Edward Terrace, Parkes
Canberra, ACT 2600, Australia

Phone +61 2 6102 7000
Fax +61 2 6102 7001
ABN: 54 74 277 1196
The National Portrait Gallery acknowledges the Ngunnawal people, the traditional custodians of the land upon which the NPG stands.